📌

Complete guide: Naep

U.S. NAEP Mathematics Trend

Grade 12 NAEP Math Scores Over Time: 2005–2024

U.S. twelfth-grade mathematics performance rose early in the comparable NAEP series, held near its high through 2013, and then moved downward. The national average reached 147 in 2024, below both the 2019 result and the 2005 starting point.

Assessment: NAEP Cycles: 2005–2024 Subject: Mathematics Population: Grade 12 students Reporting: National

Grade 12 Mathematics Trend Statistics

2024 Average Score
147
Lowest rounded national average in the comparable 2005–2024 series
Change From 2019
−3
NAEP reports the 2024 average as lower than the 2019 average
At or Above NAEP Proficient
22%
Two percentage points below 2019
Below NAEP Basic
45%
Five percentage points above 2019 under NAEP’s official comparison
90th–10th Percentile Spread
96
Points separating the rounded 90th- and 10th-percentile scores in 2024

Grade 12 NAEP Mathematics Average Score, 2005–2024

National average score for each comparable Grade 12 mathematics assessment.

The displayed vertical range is narrowed to make cycle-to-cycle movement visible. The full Grade 12 NAEP mathematics scale runs from 0 to 300.

Official data: National Center for Education Statistics, National Assessment of Educational Progress mathematics assessments.

Full Grade 12 Mathematics Score History

The current comparable series contains six assessment years. The comparison column follows NAEP’s statistical testing rather than treating every difference between rounded scores as a measurable change.

Comparison With Previous Assessment
2005150Comparable-series baseline
2009153Higher than 2005
2013153No measurable difference from 2009
2015152Lower than 2013
2019150No measurable difference from 2015
2024147Lower than 2019
The Early Gain Was Not Maintained
  • The first measurable movement was upward: the national average increased from 150 in 2005 to 153 in 2009. The 2013 result remained at a rounded 153 and was not statistically distinguishable from 2009.
  • The direction changed after 2013. NAEP identified the 2015 result as lower than 2013. The rounded average then moved from 152 in 2015 to 150 in 2019, although those two assessments were not statistically distinguishable.
  • The 2024 average of 147 was lower than both 2019 and 2005. It is also the lowest rounded national average among the six comparable Grade 12 mathematics assessments beginning in 2005.
  • Rounded scores are useful for displaying the trend, but NAEP performs comparisons with unrounded estimates. A subtraction of two displayed whole-number scores can therefore differ from the change used in NAEP’s statistical testing.

Performance at Different Points of the Score Distribution

Selected percentile scores show whether movement in the national average was shared across lower-, middle-, and higher-performing students.

Percentiles identify points in the national score distribution. The chart uses rounded published scores; official comparisons between years use unrounded estimates.

Official NAEP data with rounded percentile values tabulated by the National Center for Science and Engineering Statistics from NCES assessments.

Grade 12 Mathematics Scores by Percentile

200510512715117419489
200911013015417719787
201311113115417719786
201510712815217519689
201910412515017519692
202410012014617219696
The 2024 Decline Was Larger Below the Top of the Distribution
  • NAEP reports that from 2019 to 2024 the 10th- and 25th-percentile scores each decreased by 5 points, the median decreased by 4 points, and the 75th percentile decreased by 3 points. The 90th-percentile result was not statistically distinguishable from 2019.
  • The pattern therefore was not a uniform downward shift. The lower and middle portions of the distribution moved farther downward while the top percentile shown remained comparatively stable.
  • Using the published rounded scores, the distance between the 90th and 10th percentiles widened from 86 points in 2013 to 92 in 2019 and 96 in 2024. The 2024 spread is the widest in the comparable Grade 12 series.
  • The rounded 10th-percentile values move from 104 in 2019 to 100 in 2024, yet NAEP reports a 5-point decrease. The apparent four-point subtraction differs because official changes are calculated from unrounded estimates.

Achievement Levels Add Context to the 2024 Score

The national average does not show how students were distributed across NAEP performance standards. In 2024, 55% of twelfth-graders were at or above NAEP Basic, 22% were at or above NAEP Proficient, and 3% were at NAEP Advanced. Forty-five percent scored below NAEP Basic.

Compared With 2019Compared With 2005
At or above NAEP Basic55%5 percentage points lower5 percentage points lower under the official comparison
At or above NAEP Proficient22%2 percentage points lowerNo measurable difference
At NAEP Advanced3%No measurable difference1 percentage point higher
Below NAEP Basic45%5 percentage points higher5 percentage points higher under the official comparison
Grade 12 mathematics cut scores: NAEP Basic begins at 141, NAEP Proficient at 176, and NAEP Advanced at 216 on the current 0–300 scale.
NAEP Proficient is not the same as grade-level proficiency. It is a performance standard defined specifically for NAEP and should not be interpreted as the percentage of students meeting a state or district grade-level standard.

Why the Comparable Grade 12 Mathematics Series Begins in 2005

The Grade 12 mathematics assessment was substantially revised for 2005, and its reporting scale changed from the earlier 0–500 cross-grade scale to a 0–300 Grade 12 scale. NCES therefore begins the current Grade 12 mathematics trend with the 2005 assessment.

Results from 1990, 1992, 1996, and 2000 belong to the earlier Grade 12 mathematics series and should not be appended to the 2005–2024 line as though the measurement remained unchanged. The comparable current sequence is 2005, 2009, 2013, 2015, 2019, and 2024.

The same separation applies across grades. Grade 4 and Grade 8 mathematics scores are reported on separately derived 0–500 scales, while Grade 12 uses a separately derived 0–300 scale. A Grade 12 score of 147 cannot be compared numerically with a Grade 4 or Grade 8 score to determine which grade has higher achievement.

Grade 12 Results Are National, Not a 2024 State Ranking

The 2024 Grade 12 mathematics results represent a nationally representative sample of U.S. twelfth-graders. Unlike the main Grade 4 and Grade 8 NAEP mathematics releases, the 2024 Grade 12 report provides national results rather than a complete state-by-state reporting set.

Earlier Grade 12 administrations included limited state participation in selected years, but those results do not create a continuous 50-state series. A state ranking should therefore not be inferred from the national 2005–2024 trend shown here.

Data Sources, Measurement and Comparability

Assessment: National Assessment of Educational Progress mathematics assessment.

Population: U.S. students enrolled in Grade 12.

Geography: National results for the 2024 Grade 12 assessment.

Scale: 0–300 for the comparable Grade 12 mathematics series beginning in 2005.

Comparison basis: Published scores and percentages are rounded for display. NAEP uses unrounded estimates when calculating differences and conducting statistical tests, with a .05 testing threshold and adjustments for multiple comparisons. Apparent differences between displayed whole numbers therefore do not always represent measurable differences.

2019 administration: Grade 12 mathematics was administered digitally for the first time in 2019, with reported results combining students assigned to digitally based and paper-based versions.

Achievement levels: NAEP Basic, NAEP Proficient, and NAEP Advanced are NAEP performance standards. They remain trial achievement levels and are not equivalent to state or district definitions of grade-level proficiency.